Question: How Do You Handle Peer Review Comments?

How do you write a good peer recommendation?

Let’s break down the steps to writing a great peer recommendation, starting with brainstorming.Step 1: Brainstorm.

Ah brainstorming, that oft suggested but little used first step.

Step 2: Outline and Draft.

Letters of recommendation are typically one page.

Step 3: Revision.


Step 4: Submit Your Letter.Aug 1, 2018.

How do you respond to a peer post?

Validate the post by sharing your experience and stating how it relates to the course material or to the initial post. Agree or disagree with the post and explain why you agree or disagree. Expand on your classmate’s post to demonstrate that you understand the topic.

How do you respond to a peer review comment?

Ten simple rules for writing a response to reviewersRule 1: Provide an overview, then quote the full set of reviews.Rule 2: Be polite and respectful of all reviewers.Rule 3: Accept the blame.Rule 4: Make the response self-contained.Rule 5: Respond to every point raised by the reviewer.Rule 6: Use typography to help the reviewer navigate your response.More items…•Oct 12, 2017

How do you respond to a reviewer comment example?

I/We [use the relevant pronoun “I” or “We” here and wherever applicable throughout] appreciate the time and effort that you and the reviewers have dedicated to providing your valuable feedback on my manuscript. I am/We are grateful to the reviewers for their insightful comments on my paper.

How do I fill out a peer review form?

12-step guide to writing a peer review1) Make sure you have the right expertise. … 2) Visit the journal web page to learn their reviewer-specific instructions. … 3) Skim the paper very quickly to get a general sense of the article. … 4) Sit in a quiet place and read the manuscript critically.More items…•Nov 17, 2019

Do reviewers see each others comments?

Reviewer comments can be shared in Editorial Manager. In EM, journals can optionally share reviewer identities, reviewer comments, and decision letters with other reviewers. This means that EM supports the most common “open” peer review workflows where reviewers are allowed to see each other’s comments.

How do you write a peer response?

If you are the responder . . .Carefully listen to and/or read the draft.Answer the writer’s immediate questions.Complete a response sheet to organize your ideas.Then comment aloud about the writing. Tell what parts you like and suggest ways to make the writing even better.Always be kind and polite in your remarks.

What do you do if you don’t agree with reviewers comments?

It is absolutely fine to disagree with a reviewer’s comment. You can send a point-by-point response to the editor explaining why you disagree with the reviewer’s suggestion. Make sure your response is backed by supporting evidence. If your viewpoint is justified, the editor will definitely consider it.

What is the definition of peer response?

Peer response is the process of responding to writing at macro and micro levels and in ways that offer helpful, constructive feedback.

How do you politely disagree with a reviewer?

The key is to be polite and to provide a sound argument demonstrating your grounds for the disagreement. Daniel Wright is right. Although you are responding to the reviewer, you are primarily trying to convince the editor. Also pay careful attention to the reviewer’s comments and if possible, conduct further research.

How do you handle reviewer comments?

7 tips for dealing with reviewer commentsUse the reviewer comments even if your paper is rejected. … Be polite – but not over-polite. … Don’t feel obliged to accept everything the reviewer says. … What to do when two reviewers ask for opposite things. … Make sure you address everything. … Dealing with comments you don’t understand. … Engage the editor as an adjudicator.Oct 20, 2013

How do you give an effective peer review?

It’s crucial to understand how to give and receive effective peer reviews….Below are some recommendations we have for preparing for your peer reviews:Include specific questions. … Give some context. … Provide adequate, but not overwhelming, background. … Reference your earlier work. … Request a follow-up.

What can I say in a peer review?

DoJustify your recommendation with concrete evidence and specific examples.Be specific so the authors know what they need to do to improve.Be thorough. This might be the only time you read the manuscript.Be professional and respectful. … Remember to say what you liked about the manuscript!Feb 6, 2020

What is the main purpose of peer review?

Peer review is designed to assess the validity, quality and often the originality of articles for publication. Its ultimate purpose is to maintain the integrity of science by filtering out invalid or poor quality articles.

How do you thank a reviewer?

Thank the Reviewer Show your appreciation and make it personal. Reference specific things they mentioned like agreeing if they point out one of your stellar employees. The following example shows you actually took the time to read and appreciate what your customer wrote.

What is peer reply?

In composition studies, peer response is a form of collaborative learning in which writers meet (usually in small groups, either face-to-face or online) to respond to one another’s work. Also called peer review and peer feedback.

How do you respond to a comment?

5 Rules for Responding to CommentsBe genuinely happy to receive comments. Thanking the person for taking the time to comment is a no-brainer—yet it’s often overlooked. … Size matters. Sometimes short and sweet (like a simple, “Thanks!”) is all that’s really required. … Respond ASAP. … Don’t link in comments. … Spellcheck, spellcheck, spellcheck.

How do you write a review report example?

SummaryBegin with any positive feedback you have – if you start off on a positive note, authors will be more likely to read your review. … Try to put the findings of the paper into the context of the existing literature and current knowledge.More items…•Jan 18, 2018

Add a comment